法學期刊
  • 社群分享
論著名稱:
論醫師在計畫外生育事件的注意義務與說明義務(The Research to the Duty of Care and the Obligation of the Informed Consent which the Doctors have to Keep in the Wrongful Birth Event)
文獻引用
編著譯者: 古振暉
出版日期: 2012.10
刊登出處: 台灣/法學叢刊第 57 卷 第 4 期/95-129 頁
頁  數: 35 點閱次數: 1335
下載點數: 140 點 銷售明細: 權利金查詢 變更售價
授 權 者: 法學叢刊雜誌社
關 鍵 詞: 計畫外生育侵權行為的違法性判斷過失的客觀化醫療水準說明義務損害迴避義務預見可能性
中文摘要: 計畫外生育事件因性質上本非完全典型之醫療事故,但又涉及諸多醫療科技發展之知識,事件的結果又影響深遠,在各國均為熱烈探討之課題。同樣的,該等事件在實務審理中,應如何確定醫師之注意義務與說明義務的程度及範圍,兼顧病患與醫師間的實體正義,亦屬重要之課題。本文試從最高法院關於此類事件所表現之見解為據,觀察現行基層法院審理是類事件之觀點。又另從理論面闡述侵權行為違法性判斷之基準,對於醫師治療時所應盡注意義務-「醫療水準」的具體判斷基準-之內涵,確立其較具體可行的準則,並探討醫師說明義務之法律上地位及效果,以期確定說明義務未履行在該類事件的責任基礎。復以理論面所建構的結論,檢討現行實務的觀點,希望使是類事件之審理能有更加週全及具體的正義分配。
英文關鍵詞: wrongful birth, illegal judgment of torts, objective negligence, medical level, informed consent, the duty of avoid damage, the possibility of foreseeable
英文摘要: Although wrongful birth event is not typical medical event, these events always not only involve many medical technology knowledge which is under development, the results of the event but also bring deeply influence to parties concerned. Therefore it become a enthusiastic discussion problem in various countries. It is also a important viewpoint for taking into account the substantive justice between the doctor and the patients that how to define the scope of diligence duty and informed consent duty of doctor about wrongful birth event in legal action. This article try to build the base on the opinion of Supreme Court proclaimed in wrongful birth case, besides, observe the common viewpoint in wrongful birth case of Taiwan district court. Furthermore, expound the torts theory about standard which can establish so called “Medical level” criterion doctor must obey in medical event. In addition, explore the legal status and efficacy of doctor’s duty of the “Informed Consent” for looking forward to realize the foundation of liability when the doctor breach of duty of the informed consent. In the end, the article want to review what way of dealing with wrongful birth event in judicial justice through the conclusion from the law theory built on, in order to impel this sort of trial can be more thoughtful and more justice.
目  次: 壹、前言
貳、新光醫院唐氏症事件與地方法院實務案例分析
參、理論的介紹與檢討
肆、最高法院見解之評析與地方法院實務案例分析
伍、結論
相關法條:
相關判解:
相關函釋:
相關論著:
古振暉,論醫師在計畫外生育事件的注意義務與說明義務,法學叢刊,第 57 卷 第 4 期,95-129 頁,2012年10月。
返回功能列